Let’s start with an anecdote.
(I’ll italicize this part so you can skip down to the actual review, if you wish.)
Back in the last PCA/ACA conference, I attended a paper on Becky Rosen, Supernatural creator’s once love-letter to the fans that turned sour, gross and downright ugly. Becky, who represents the fans, tied Sam Winchester onto the bed and took of his pants, after drugging him and basically taking advantage of him by making him marry her. Luckily for him, Dean stepped in to correct it all. If I remember correctly, the paper argued that Sam’s body represented the text, The paper argued that in this case, Sam’s body represented Supernatural as a text, and Dean represented the writers of the show. The fans, fans like Becky (note: a straight female who wants nothing more but to get into Sam’s pants), are unstable and have no concepts of boundaries. She, the paper argues, is a threat to Sam, meaning the fans are a threat to the text. Basically, the whole thing was a big screw you to the fans.
When Charlie was first introduced as a character, she was introduced as a fan. The good kind. Hermione Granger, Wonder Woman fan, smart cookie and a social liberal hacktivist who donates superpacks to charities. She also takes on almost a little sister role in the Winchester’s life, especially Dean, making her a Winchester ally (at this point, I was thinking she was going to die, because what woman ever survived being a Winchester friend?).
Over all, what’s not to like? Compared to Becky, she was a refreshing, and non-pejorative representation of the fan in the show.
Then she was revealed as a lesbian. Ah. I see. I see what you did there, SPN writers. Becky is bad, and Charlie is good, because one wants to get into the boy’s pants, while the other doesn’t want anything to do with that crap at all. Lesbian? You’re not a threat. You’re a fan, but you’re not a threat, so you’re OK.
Anyways, those are my first thoughts about our dear Charlie.
This episode was very interesting. Let’s start with good things I really liked. Tons of popular culture references. The boys geeking out (Dean especially). LARPing. Somewhat representation of geek culture. Good ol’ classic throwback to monster-of-the-week. Felicia Day.
These things were pretty self-explanatory.
Now down to the nitty gritty.
Check out my title. I laughed when I wrote it, because really. The queen wants to bang the fairy. Hah. *snort* Anyways, one of the things I liked about Charlie when she was first introduced was the fact that her queerness did not make her who she is. She was this awesome, tech-savvy cute little nerd girl who just happened to be gay. I adored that about her. This episode was definitely different. At every turn, it was like, “Charlie is gay, viewer. See that, she is gay. LOOK, she is totally shameless about it, wanting to screw people in her tent. She’s sexually liberated and gay! Did I mention, TOTALLY GAY?!”
Seriously. It kind of reminded me of Route 666 way back in first season, which was SPN’s TOTALLY NOT RACIST EPISODE, because look, black people! And, and, and Dean is dating one of them. Seriously, not racist.
Except for the fact the MOTW was a ghost of a white man that’s killing all of them.
Again, I digress. Basically, this factor of the episode was what irked me the most. Representation of queer characters in the media, even now, are few and far between. Most of the time they are stereotypically, or too problematic, or the character is just the gay character and nothing else. Charlie’s introduction on show was good because her queerness did not make who she is, but this episode definitely erased that for me.
Now, one can argue that this representation is totally not problematic in that Charlie is just doing what any heterosexual male in the show (ie: Dean), would have done. And why should be any different if she’s a lesbian? Lesbians can look and oggle at girls and be sexually suggestive as well! Your argument makes no sense, Mariel, get a life!
Yeah, maybe. Maybe this argument is not sound. What I am trying to point out is this: regardless of thinky thoughts of what Charlie represents for the writers, her character started as a concrete person who just happened to be gay, and that’s fine. The fact that she sleeps with women did not make who she is. And that was how the episode started, with her and Dean being in sync of knowing a female porn star was a good little quirk that was reminiscent of her first episode. Then after that, it was like she was almost predatory. Every turn she was propositioning sex to every female LARPer, and the ending? Seriously. The Queen just saved that Fairy because she thought she was going to bang her.
Sigh. Ultimately, I felt like Supernatural did it again. They took something that first turned out to be good, then splatted all over it. Becky was a love letter to the fans that got burnt in front of the fans faces, and Charlie was the character who just happened to be gay ginger, and now she’s just a ginger lesbian.